Trump would like to
say to Dr. Anthony Fauci “you are fired”, but he knows better not
to do it because of the potential repercussion and backfire. He
found the alternative by hiring Dr. Scott Atlas as a new medical
adviser for the White House coronavirus task force, it is a perfect
fit.
If one wonders why
such an excellent doctor and scholar in academic medicine would
embrace views that align with that of President Trump when it comes
to the management of this horrendous pandemic. (Dr. Atlas served as
the head of the neuroradiology at Stanford University Medical Center
from 1998 to 2012, specializing in MRI, currently a senior fellow in
health care policy at Hoover Institution, a conservative think tank
at Stanford University. He is the editor of Magnetic Resonance
Imaging of the Brain and Spine, a leading textbook in the field.)
Biased thought it
may be, I’ll offer my analysis. I am hoping you will find it
fair, reasonable and credible.
Like
Trump, he has no empathy (I do not know him enough to say whether he
is narcissistic or not.) He said for young people to get Covid-19 is
a good thing, if fact, he wants about 60% of people in the community
to get infected, thus producing antibody. He lamented the
lockdown prevented natural herd immunity from happening.
Without empathy he cannot feel the pain that how many Americans have
to die or suffer.
Like
trump, he belittles the threat of the pandemic, ridiculing the
“hysteria” surrounding the coronavirus, such as parents’
concern and worry for kids going to schools. In a 4/13/2020
article published in The Hill, he wrote, “with a world-wide sense
of relief, progress continues containing the COVID-19 pandemic.”
He also wrote that aside from New York, the vast majorities of
American hospitals were not overwhelmed beyond capacity. The
summer surge in the sun belt states proves his prediction was wrong and overly optimism unwarranted.
Like
Trump, he has no respect of the expertise of others’ fields.
Trump once said he knows more about NATO than Marine Corp General
Mattis who once served as the NATO Supreme Allied Commander.
Dr. Atlas is an expert in MRI medicine and health care policy, but
he has no experience in dealing with infectious disease, let alone
pandemic. Like Trump, he treated Dr. Fauci as an alarmist.
Like Trump, Dr. Atlas advocates "safely" reopening the economy and schools in a hurry and wants the college sports back now. The University of North Carolina was just forced to cancel in-person classes after at least 130 students tested positive in the first week of the semester.

American media can
be biased reporting the radical views of Dr. Atlas. I came
across an article in a German newspaper, Frankfurter Allgemeine
(8/17/2020), with a title of “Sie simulieren Wissenschaft” (they
feign/fake science), the title picture of the article shows a picture
of Dr. Scott Atlas, one can see “corona-pseudoexperten”
(corona-pseudo experts). Unfortunately this article is not a free
access without subscription, I can only read the first few
paragraphs, which are about pseudo experts on climate change. I cannot
tell you what they said about Dr. Atlas, but based on the title and
the picture of the article, they most likely consider him a pseudo
expert as Trump’s adviser. Even his own university (Stanford U) has backed off plans to offer in-person classes this fall.
While talking about President Trump, German media are no less critical than New York Times, Washington Post, CNN and MSNBC. This article is just an example.
In my view, a doctor
of his repute and caliber, Dr. Atlas’ radical approach in
dealing with this pandemic is irresponsible (some said "naive"), or even reckless, and
could do damage to the society.